Washington DC / New Delhi, September 08(HS): Elon Musk has defended the credibility of his social media platform X’s fact-checking mechanism after former Trump aide Peter Navarro launched a fresh tirade against India over its Russian oil imports. Navarro, who accused New Delhi of “profiteering” and fueling Moscow’s war machine, was hit with Community Notes fact-checks that flagged his claims as misleading and hypocritical.
Without naming Navarro directly, Musk responded, writing on X:
“On this platform, the people decide the narrative. You hear all sides of an argument. Community Notes corrects everyone, no exceptions. Notes, data, and code are open-source. Grok provides further fact-checking.”
Navarro’s Charges
Navarro alleged that India buys Russian oil “solely for profit,” calling it part of a “laundromat for the Kremlin,” and argued that US jobs were being lost due to “India’s high tariffs.” He further claimed that Indian revenues from oil trade were funding Russia’s war in Ukraine.
“India buys Russian oil solely to profiteer. Indian govt spin machine moving high tilt. Stop killing Ukrainians. Stop taking American jobs,” Navarro posted.
X’s Fact-Checks
Community Notes immediately pushed back:
-India’s oil imports from Russia are for “energy security” and “do not violate sanctions.”
-The US continues to import commodities like uranium from Russia, exposing a “clear double standard.”
-While India does levy some tariffs, the US has a trade surplus with New Delhi in services.
One note stated directly: “Navarro’s claims are hypocritical. India’s legal, sovereign purchases of Russian oil for energy security do not violate international law.”
In response, Navarro slammed Musk: “Wow. @elonmusk is letting propaganda into people’s posts. That crap note below is just that. Crap.”
Rising Tensions in India–US Trade Ties
The spat comes amid worsening trade relations, with President Trump recently imposing an additional 25 percent duty on Indian exports, raising tariffs to over 50 percent—some of the highest under his administration. Navarro has repeatedly tied India’s Russian oil purchases to the continuation of the Ukraine conflict, labeling it “Modi’s war.”
Meanwhile, Prime Minister Narendra Modi, attending the SCO Summit in Tianjin alongside Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, signaled strategic unity with major powers outside the US orbit. Trump initially lamented that America had “lost India to China” but later softened, calling India “a very special partner.” Modi reciprocated, emphasizing that he and Trump remain “friends” despite trade friction.
—————
Hindusthan Samachar / Jun Sarkar
