
Srinagar- The High Court of J&K and Ladakh has upheld a penalty of Rs 2.5 lakh imposed on Indian Oil Corporation for operating a petrol pump at Letpora in south Kashmir’s Pulwama district without obtaining final access permission from the National Highway Administration.
A bench of Justice Sanjay Dhar, while disposing of a writ petition, directed the District Magistrate/Deputy Commissioner, Pulwama, to conduct an enquiry into whether the retail outlet, operating under the name M/s Fatima Filling Station, was established at the sanctioned location in compliance with the relevant rules and after obtaining all requisite No Objection Certificates (NOCs).
The court also directed the district administration to remove encroachments obstructing the construction of an approach road to the outlet.
The petitioner had challenged a communication dated July 28, 2025, through which the National Highway Authority directed the Chief Manager, Retail Sales, Indian Oil Corporation, to deposit a penalty of Rs 2.5 lakh for energising the fuel station without obtaining final access permission. The communication had also ordered de-energisation of the outlet until the grant of the requisite permission.
The petitioner maintained that the petrol pump had been established after obtaining the necessary clearances under the Petroleum Act, 1934, and Petroleum Rules, 2002, besides securing provisional access permission from the National Highway Authority in February 2021.
The petitioner contended that the final access permission remained pending because of encroachments by local residents and shopkeepers on National Highway land, which the authorities had “failed to remove despite repeated representations.”
The National Highway Authority, on the other hand, justified the penalty, maintaining that the fuel station had been energised and commercial operations commenced without final access permission, in violation of the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways guidelines issued on June 26, 2020.
Upholding the penalty, the court held that the guidelines clearly prohibit energisation of a fuel station on the basis of provisional access permission and mandate regular access permission before commencement of operations.
“Without constructing the access to the petrol pump, the same cannot be energized in any circumstances whatsoever,” the court observed.
It, however, noted that the construction of the access road had been impeded by encroachments which neither the National Highway Authority nor the district administration had succeeded in removing. The court observed that the circumstances could justify seeking an extension of provisional access permission and additional time for construction of the approach road, but could not legitimise operation of the petrol pump without final approval.
On the issue of encroachments, the court held that any unauthorised occupation of National Highway land, irrespective of who was responsible, must be removed in accordance with the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002.
The court observed that the District Magistrate was empowered under Sections 26, 27, 36 and 43 of the Act to facilitate the speedy removal of such encroachments.
Referring to the Supreme Court’s directions in Gyan Prakash vs Union of India, the court said the District Magistrate, Pulwama, was duty-bound to ensure removal of all encroachments on National Highway land that were preventing construction of the access road to the petrol pump.
The court accordingly directed the District Magistrate to examine whether the outlet had been established in accordance with the applicable rules and after obtaining all requisite departmental clearances.
It ordered that if the enquiry establishes compliance with all requirements, the outlet shall be allowed to operate at the sanctioned location. Any encroachment obstructing construction of its access road shall also be removed by the district administration in accordance with law.
Following construction of the access road, the National Highway Authority shall grant final access permission and allow the petrol pump to be energised, the court directed.
However, if deficiencies are detected during the enquiry, the petitioner shall be given an opportunity to rectify them, failing which the outlet shall be closed down or sealed.




